Real Estate Appraisal Expert Not Allowed to Opine on the Appropriate Measure of Lost Value

Posted on November 20, 2026 by Shuva Guha Thakurta

This case arises out of damage to real property. In their Petition, which was initially filed in state court, Plaintiffs, The Campbell Group, LLC ("Campbell Group") and JP Fields Group, LLC ("JP Fields Group"), alleged that on August 31, 2023, Defendant Shamar X. Jackson was operating a commercial vehicle owned by DG when he collided with the northeast corner of Plaintiffs' restaurant property in Clayton, Missouri.

Plaintiffs alleged that the collision caused significant damage to the restaurant, and following a contested hearing, the City of Clayton ordered that the building be demolished.

Plaintiffs claimed that Defendant Jackson, an agent of DG, breached his duty of care to operate the vehicle in a manner so as not to present a hazard to Plaintiffs or the public. They contended that Defendant Jackson negligently or recklessly failed to keep his vehicle under proper control and failed to brake, steer, or otherwise maneuver to avoid colliding with the restaurant building. Plaintiffs sought damages, plus attorneys' fees, and pre-and post-judgment interest. Defendants sought to exclude the testimony of Plaintiffs' expert, Ernest A. Demba.

Real Estate Appraisal Expert Not Allowed to Opine on the Appropriate Measure of Lost Value

Real Estate Appraisal Expert Witness

Ernest Alan Demba is a state-certified real estate appraiser. Demba has taught for Washington University in St. Louis in the University College Division for the Economics Department and has taught for Lindenwood Colleges (now Lindenwood University) in their Valuation Sciences Degree Program leading to both an undergraduate degree and a master’s degree in Valuation Science. Demba has also taught internationally to students from the former communist bloc countries in Eastern Europe.

Want to know more about the challenges Ernest Demba has faced? Get the full details with our Challenge Study report.

Discussion by the Court

Defendants sought to prevent Demba from testifying that the property at issue lacked determinable market values before and after the collision, and that the value of the property should be determined by the replacement cost of the building. Defendants argued, among other things, that Demba's opinions have insufficient factual foundation and are not founded in proper methodology.

Plaintiffs disclosed a Retrospective Appraisal Report Demba prepared dated July 25, 2025. In his report, Demba stated that the purpose of the report is to express his opinion of the "100% fee simple ownership value benefit in the before damage condition and do a valuation of the denied after damage property benefit." In other words, "the assignment is to result in an opinion of the value of the 100% fee simple interest in the subject property before and after the described damage event as of the date of the event."

Demba opined that the fair market value of the subject property, before and after the collision, cannot be determined using the comparative sales approach. He opined that before the collision, the subject property had features that made it a unique property, including that the building filled nearly the whole footprint of the property; it lacked on-site parking; it was an older one-story building; and it was not on the "main thoroughfare" in downtown Clayton. Demba defined the relevant market for the subject property as a small area consisting of north downtown Clayton, and he examined property sales within that area from 2016 forward.

Demba evaluated four property sales in the defined relevant market, but he found that they were not meaningful for purposes of determining the fair market value of the subject property, because the properties had different attributes and features and were not comparable to the property at issue. Demba further found that the four sales could not be adjusted for comparison to the subject property because: (1) some of the buyers' or sellers' motivations were not market driven; (2) the properties did not have adjustable differences that could be abstracted from market transactions; and/or (3) there were other factors that made the transfers other than an open market transfer. Based on the data he used, Demba found that the sales comparison approach could not be used to value the subject property.

Demba concluded that replacement cost is the appropriate approach to measure the value of the Plaintiffs' loss in this case. Plaintiffs provided Demba with a cost estimate from ARCO Construction, Inc. to design and build a replacement restaurant structure on the subject property. Notably, Demba wrote in his report that he had not inspected the restaurant before the accident, and he "had not been furnished with a comparison of the details of how this replacement structure matches the damaged structure," but he found ARCO Construction, Inc.'s estimate of $5,149,400.00 to rebuild a restaurant structure on the property was "well within the cost range of replacing the restaurant structure on the subject site."

Demba also found that following the collision, the subject property, with the restaurant building condemned, torn down, and removed, offered no value whatsoever to Plaintiffs. Therefore, according to Demba, the "Final Value Opinion before the damage" is $5,149,400.00, the "Final Value Opinion after the damage" is $0.00, and the "Measure of Total Damage" is $5,149,400.00. Demba concludes his report by writing, "Based on the application of the appraisal process, the data, the analysis, and the reasoning in this report, I conclude an opinion of the loss in total value of the benefits offered to [Plaintiffs] for the subject property due to the damage described herein as of the effect date of value to be: $5,149,400."

Motion to Exclude

Defendants argued that Demba's opinions are not supported by sufficient facts, and he failed to use a reliable methodology that is accepted in his field. Defendants do not challenge Demba's qualifications as an expert in the field of property appraisal.

Defendants sought to exclude Demba from offering the following opinions:

1. The subject property lacked a determinable fair market value;

2. Comparable sales data was unavailable for purposes of market valuation;

3. The property was so unique that market value can not be calculated; and

4. Replacement cost is the appropriate measure of value because the property's market value cannot be determined.

The Court addressed Demba's opinion that the subject property cannot be appraised using the comparable sales approach, which is an accepted method for determining the fair market value of real property. The comparable sales approach analyzes arm's-length sales of similar properties in the community that are proximate in time. The approach recognizes that no two properties are exactly alike, and there may be differences in size, surroundings, location, and use. Under the comparable sales approach, the differences between the comparable properties and the subject property are evaluated, and adjustments are made to the comparables' sale prices to calculate the market value of the subject property.

In evaluating the value of the subject property, Demba did look at sales in the immediate surrounding area. He found, however, that the sales were not comparable for various reasons, and he ultimately concluded the value of the subject property could not be calculated based on this approach. Defendants fault Demba's methodology and argued that he defined the relevant market area too narrowly. Defendants point to the fact that Demba selected a very narrow market area that was only a few blocks in size, which was inconsistent with the methodology he employed on other appraisal assignments. However, in his report and during deposition, Demba explained why he defined the relevant market area as he did, and Defendants have not shown that the decision was based on a flawed methodology. Defendants will be allowed to question Demba about his decision to use such a small market area on cross-examination, but Defendants have not established that his opinion should be excluded on this basis.

Defendants also fault Demba's methodology because he failed to make adjustments to the property sales he did uncover in his market search. They again point to the fact that he has adjusted for differences, such as size and location, in prior appraisals. Defendants also note that their expert was able to make adjustments to property sales in the area in order to make comparisons to the subject property. In his report and during deposition, Demba again offered reasons as to why he could not adjust sales in the relevant area for comparison to the subject property. Some of these reasons rely on his own opinion and experience as an appraiser, but Missouri courts do recognize that there is a subjective aspect to calculating the fair market value of a property using the comparative sales approach, and appraisers may rely on their own experience in the field.

Defendants will be allowed to cross-examine Demba about his decision not to calculate adjustments, but his failure to do so is not a reason to exclude his testimony regarding his rejection of the comparable sales approach. The Court found Demba's opinion that comparable sales data were unavailable for purposes of market valuation is admissible, although the factual basis for this opinion will be subject to cross-examination.

As for the other opinions Defendants seek to exclude, the Court found Defendants' arguments have merit. Demba opined the subject property was so unique that its market value could not be calculated, and that it lacked a determinable fair market value. Demba reached these conclusions because he determined there were insufficient data to calculate the value of the property based on the comparable sales approach. The calculation of a property's fair market value is not limited to comparable sales.

Up until the time of the collision, the subject property was operating as a restaurant. Demba admitted that before it was damaged, the property was marketable, and in fact, Campbell Group had purchased it approximately three and a half years prior to the collision for $1,275,000.00. Demba's opinion that he was unable to calculate the property's fair market value using the comparable sales approach is admissible, but his broader opinions that the subject property lacks a determinable fair market value or that the property was so unique that a market value could not be calculated are not admissible, as they are not supported by the evidence.

Finally, Demba's opinion that replacement cost is the appropriate measure of Plaintiffs' loss is not admissible. The appropriate measure of damages is an issue of law for the Court to determine.

As discussed in more detail below, under Missouri law, replacement cost can be used as a measure of damages for a claim of tortious injury to property, but its use is limited to certain circumstances. In his report, Demba opined that the replacement cost is the appropriate measure of loss in this case based on his analysis of what he characterizes as applicable federal law.

In his report, Demba writes, "From the above [legal] analysis, I conclude that Replacement Value or Replacement Cost is the appropriate standard of value to measure the value of the actual [Plaintiffs'] loss due to the uniqueness of the subject property as written above." Demba is not an attorney or legal expert, and the cases he identified in his report are neither applicable nor from controlling authority. But more fundamentally, expert testimony offering legal opinions is not admissible, because matters of law are for the Court to decide. Demba's opinion that replacement cost is the appropriate measure of value in this case is a legal conclusion, and it will be excluded as evidence.

Defendants also raised other challenges to the ultimate admissibility of Demba's opinion. They spotlight the fact that during his deposition, Demba admitted that he was not asked to give an opinion as to the fair market value of the property for the day before Defendant Jackson struck the restaurant. He also testified that he did not have an opinion as to what the fair market value of the property was as of the date of his deposition on November 4, 2025. He further testified that he was asked to value the damage to the building, in other words, the damage to the "bricks and mortar." Defendants argued that Demba started with the conclusion that replacement cost was the appropriate measure of damages and worked backward. Defendants' theory is disputed, as Demba denied Defendants' characterization of his report. It is for the trier of fact, not the Court, to determine Demba's credibility. The Court declined to exclude Demba on these grounds, but Defendants will be allowed to cross-examine Demba on these issues.

In sum, Demba will be allowed to testify that he was unable to locate comparable sales for the subject property within the limited area that he defined as the relevant market area. He also will be allowed to testify as to why he believes properties sold in this defined area were not comparable to the property at issue. However, Demba will not be allowed to testify that the subject property lacked a determinable fair market value; that the property was so unique that a fair market value cannot be calculated; and that replacement cost is the appropriate measure of loss of value or damages.

Held

The Court granted in part and denied in part Defendants' motion to exclude the opinions of Ernest A. Demba. The motion is granted to the extent that Ernest A. Demba will not be allowed to offer opinions that (1) the subject property lacked a determinable fair market value; (2) that the subject property was so unique that a fair market value cannot be calculated; and (3) that replacement cost is the appropriate measure of lost value or damages in this case. In all other respects, Defendants' motion is denied.

Key Takeaway

When expert opinions are little more than legal conclusions, there is no abuse of discretion in excluding such statements.

Case Details:

Case Caption:

The Campbell Group, LLC v. Jackson

Docket Number:

4:24cv1080

Court Name:

United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri, Eastern Division

Order Date:

November 17, 2026