Mechanical Engineering Expert Allowed to Opine on Assembly Instructions
Posted on November 18, 2026 by Shuva Guha Thakurta
This is a products-liability case. On July 04, 2022, Justin and Abigail Krieg placed their infant son, R.K., in a Graco-manufactured swing. Later that night, they found nine-month-old R.K. "partially hanging from the swing and unresponsive." R.K. died because of his injuries.
The Kriegs used a DuetConnect, a motorized swing equipped with a five-point harness. The manual and swing itself included warnings stating not to leave children unattended in the swing, that the swing was not "safe for sleep," and to "ALWAYS use the restraints and adjust to fit accordingly."
The Kriegs testify that Justin Krieg assembled the swing, following the manual's instructions. The Kriegs did not remember if they reviewed other parts of the manual besides the assembly instructions. After the initial assembly, Justin Krieg had periodically disassembled the swing to clean it. The Kriegs routinely used the swing for R.K.'s daily naps. They secured R.K. with the swing's lap belt but not its shoulder straps.
The Kriegs brought design-defect, marketing-defect, and negligence claims against Graco. Both parties designated experts in support of their claims. Relevant here, the Kriegs designated (1) Dr. Wayne Li, a human-factors and warnings expert, to testify about the swing's instructions; (2) Dr. Erin Mannen, a biomechanical expert, to testify about the swing's alleged seatback-design defect; and (3) Dr. William Singhose, a mechanical-engineering expert, to testify about the product's alleged design defects. Graco designated (1) Dr. Jay P. Goldsmith, a medical expert; and (2) Dr. Michael T. Prange, a biomechanical-engineering expert, to provide alternative causation testimony. Dr. Prange would also testify about the swing's design.

Neonatology Expert Witness
Jay Paul Goldsmith, M.D. is a neonatologist practicing in academic and private practice for over 48 years.
Biomechanical Engineering Expert Witnesses
Michael Thomas Prange, Ph.D., P.E. is a biomechanical engineer specializing in issues involving human injury biomechanics and occupant kinematics to assess the severity and mechanism of injury incurred during traumatic events. Prange has years of experience assessing the unique aspects involved in pediatric biomechanics and injuries.
Erin M. Mannen earned a Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering with a focus in biomechanics and biomaterials from the University of Kansas, completed a Postdoctoral Fellowship in the Center for Orthopaedic Biomechanics within the Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering at the University of Denver, and has been researching biomechanics for over 15 years.
Human Factors Expert Witness
Wayne K. Li holds a Master of Science in Engineering from Stanford University and undergraduate degrees in Fine Arts in Design and Mechanical Engineering from the University of Texas at Austin.
His career spans industry and academia. Li has led innovation and market expansion for Pottery Barn seasonal home products, taught in Stanford University's design program, led interface development at Volkswagen of America's Electronics Research Laboratory, and developed corporate brand and vehicle differentiation strategies at Ford Motor Company.
Mechanical Engineering Expert Witness
William E. Singhose, Ph.D. holds a B.S. degree in Mechanical Engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, an M.S. degree in Mechanical Engineering from Stanford University, and a Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering from MIT. Singhose’s research and teaching specialties include mechanical design, human-machine interfaces, dynamics, controls, and rehabilitation engineering.
Discussion by the Court
A. The Kriegs' motion to exclude certain expert testimony and opinions of Dr. Goldsmith, Graco's medical expert
Graco designated Goldsmith to testify about the causes of and contributing factors to R.K.'s death. The Kriegs moved to exclude any testimony or opinions by Goldsmith on (1) whether the subject swing caused R.K.'s death; (2) the design and engineering opinions of the Kriegs' experts, Mannen and Singhose; and (3) "speculative opinions that are not offered within a reasonable degree of medical probability." The Kriegs first argued that Goldsmith is not qualified to offer design-causation opinions. They then argued that his opinion that proper use of the swing would have prevented "abnormal positioning" is cumulative because another Graco expert offers the same opinion. Finally, the Kriegs argued that Goldsmith's opinion that R.K.'s medical condition may have contributed to R.K.'s death is speculative.
1. Goldsmith is qualified to testify about whether the Kriegs' misuse of the swing contributed to R.K.'s death
The parties agreed that Goldsmith is qualified to give medical opinions. Instead, the Kriegs argued that the Court should disallow Goldsmith from offering design opinions because he is unqualified "to offer biomechanical or engineering opinions." But Goldsmith's opinions have to do with the Kriegs' alleged improper use of the swing as a factor in R.K.'s death. His opinions are not about the swing's design. For example, Goldsmith opined that R.K.'s death "was more likely than not due to the unsafe use of the product in a manner contrary to its warnings and instructions." The Court agreed that these are medical opinions. Graco has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Goldsmith is qualified to opine whether the swing's design caused or contributed to R.K.'s death from a medical perspective.
2. Goldsmith is qualified to rebut the medical conclusions underlying the opinions of Mannen and Singhose
The Kriegs likewise argued that Goldsmith is unqualified to rebut opinions of the Kriegs' engineering experts, Mannen and Singhose.
Graco argued that the opinions of Mannen and Singhose "necessarily rest on medical assumptions—most critically, the assumption that the seat angle or chin-to-chest positioning in the swing could cause fatal asphyxia in a 9-month-old infant." Singhose "defers to medical doctors on whether any particular position presents a risk of respiratory injury." Graco has shown that Goldsmith is more likely than not qualified to rebut the medical conclusions underlying the engineering opinions of Mannen and Singhose. Goldsmith would offer medical, not engineering opinions.
3. Goldsmith's alternative-causation opinions are not speculative
The Kriegs took issue with Goldsmith's alternative-causation opinions, arguing that they are not offered "within a reasonable degree of medical probability."
The Court's concern is reliability. Here, Goldsmith's "primary opinion" is "that R.K.'s death was 'more likely than not' due to [Sudden Unexpected Infant Death]." Goldsmith would opine as to the factors he thinks caused R.K.'s death based on the "triple risk theory," used to determine the cause of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. He reviewed photographs, investigative materials, the Kriegs' depositions, the Kriegs' experts' reports, product information, medical records, litigation documents, and a surrogate demonstration attended by Zoom. He applied the triple risk theory to the facts of the case that he learned from reviewing the materials. The Court found that Graco has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Goldsmith's opinions reflect a reliable application of reliable principles and methods to these facts.
4. Goldsmith's alternative-causation opinions are not cumulative
Goldsmith would opine that using the shoulder straps would have prevented R.K.'s death. The Kriegs argued that the Court should disallow Goldsmith from giving this testimony at trial because Prange offers the same opinion. But Goldsmith gave this opinion from a medical perspective, discussing the failure to use the five-point harness as a risk factor under the "triple risk theory" model. Prange offered the opinion from a biomechanical perspective. In his report, Prange writes that "the 5-point straps secure the child ... and do not allow the child to reach a position outside the seat frame." So Goldsmith's opinion is not "needlessly cumulative" under Rule 403. Moreover, the Kriegs fail to show that any risk of presenting a cumulative opinion substantially outweighs the testimony's probative value.
Because the Court found that Graco has met its burden in showing that Goldsmith's opinions are relevant and reliable, it denied the Kriegs' motion to exclude his testimony.
B. The Kriegs' motion to exclude certain expert testimony and opinions of Dr. Prange, Graco's biomechanical-engineer expert
Graco designated Prange to testify about the swing's design and to support Graco's alternative causation theories. The Kriegs asked the Court to preclude Prange from testifying that (1) the swing was sold with pre-threaded shoulder straps; (2) Graco's design process for the swing was "thorough, reasonable, and consistent with industry consensus;" (3) the swing's lap straps were not snugly adjusted at the time of the incident; and (4) the swing's design does not position an infant in a way that would increase the risk of positional asphyxia.
1. Prange's shoulder-strap, design-process, and lap-strap testimony are based on sufficient facts
The Kriegs argued that Prange's opinions are unreliable because they are based on insufficient facts or data. Prange's opinion that shoulder straps would have avoided R.K.'s death is based on a conversation with a Graco employee and his experience with an exemplar swing. Prange's design-process opinion is based on Graco testing and design documents, third-party testing documents, Graco's work with third-party organizations to develop standards, and conversations with Graco employees. And Prange's lap-strap opinion is based on a surrogate test he performed. The Court found that each opinion has a factual basis. An expert opinion's basis usually goes to weight rather than admissibility.
The Kriegs may challenge Prange's opinions on these grounds at trial. Graco has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Prange's testimony is based on sufficient facts or data.
2. Prange's opinion that the swing's design does not place infants at risk of positional asphyxia is the product of reliable methodology
The Kriegs claimed that Graco did not sufficiently disclose the methodology that Prange used to determine that a child would not be at risk of positional asphyxia if the restraint system is used. But Prange explained the methodology he used in his studies in his expert report. Prange analyzed an exemplar with a surrogate child, using the lap belt but not the shoulder straps. The Kriegs also criticized the amount of time Prange spent on the study, and that the surrogate child used in the testing was older and larger than R.K. was at the time of the incident. Graco correctly responded that such issues with the study's methodology go to the weight of the evidence and are the proper subject of cross-examination at trial. Graco has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Prange's testimony is the product of reliable methods.
The Court denied the Kriegs' motion to exclude Prange's testimony because Graco has shown the Court that Prange's testimony is more likely than not based on sufficient facts and is the product of reliable methods.
C. Graco's motion to exclude certain expert testimony and opinions of Li, the Kriegs' human-factors and warnings expert
The Kriegs designated Li to testify about the swing's instructions and warnings. Graco asked the Court to preclude Li from testifying or opining (1) that the swing is difficult to assemble and the instructions can be improved; (2) about why Justin Krieg failed to use the swing's shoulder straps; and (3) that different on-product labels would have changed the case's outcome.
1. Li's opinion that the deficient instructions made the swing difficult to assemble is based on reliable methodology
The Kriegs must establish by a preponderance of the evidence that Li's opinion that the swing's instructions were deficient was the product of reliable methodology.
Li's methodology was to assemble an exemplar swing using the swing's instruction manual. He also used his warnings and human-factors expertise in reaching his opinions. According to the Kriegs, personal assembly is recognized as a proper methodology for human-factors opinions. Graco does not "challenge the general use of exemplars by expert witnesses." Rather, it challenged the fact that Li assembled a previously disassembled exemplar rather than a new product. This argument is discussed below. The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Li's methodology, personal assembly of an exemplar swing, is a reliable methodology based on the case's facts.
2. Li's opinion about difficult assembly is based on sufficient facts
The Kriegs must also establish by a preponderance of the evidence that Li's deficient-instruction opinion was based on sufficient facts. Li based his opinion on a previously disassembled exemplar swing. Justin Krieg had previously disassembled and re-assembled the Kriegs' swing before R.K.'s death.
So using a previously disassembled swing more closely matches the facts here than using a new swing. Li also "reviewed thousands of pages of material in this case," including the Kriegs' depositions, the instruction manuals, and the on-product warning labels. The Kriegs have shown that this opinion is more likely than not based on sufficient facts.
3. Li's difficult-assembly opinion is sufficiently tied to the facts of the case
Graco argued that Li's testimony that the swing's assembly instructions rendered assembling the swing difficult does not fit the facts of this case.
Li said he had difficulty assembling the swing, but Justin Krieg said he did not. But Li explained that a user who omits a step he was never instructed to perform will believe he assembled the product correctly.
The Kriegs stated that Li's testimony and opinion will help explain why Justin Krieg did not have the shoulder straps properly assembled, a fact which is at issue. The Court found the Kriegs' argument persuasive and that this opinion sufficiently fits the facts.
4. Li's general opinion, that consumers may not have known to use the shoulder straps because of the swing's instructions, is not speculative; but any testimony as to the Kriegs' subjective thoughts or knowledge would be speculative
Graco argued that Li's "speculative theories about why [Justin] Krieg did not use the shoulder straps with R.K. ... are untethered to the evidentiary record."
Li opined that, by not including "a definitive step instructing how to feed the shoulder straps through the seat pad, Graco jeopardizes and compromises the correct use of the safety restraint system." This omission "is a source of error for end customers[, who] could improperly buckle their infant into the product by using only the lap and crotch belt." Justin Krieg only used the lap belt to restrain R.K. and testified that "he believed the waist strap alone was sufficient."
Li based this opinion about "end customers" on his review of the instruction manual, which failed to instruct consumers on how to feed the shoulder straps into the swing chair. This general opinion does not contradict Justin Krieg's testimony that he did not think he needed to use the shoulder straps. It explains that fact, which is at issue. So the opinion is relevant. And this general opinion is reliably based on his human-factors expertise, not any speculation into Justin Krieg's subjective knowledge.
In his deposition, Li stated that his "feeling" is that Justin Krieg did not know how to thread the shoulder straps through the back of the seat. He also suggested that Justin Krieg may have forgotten about the shoulder straps. He testified that the problem is the manual's failure to instruct users to put the shoulder straps through the seatback. He bases this testimony on his "feeling" and his ability to "imagine being a harried parent." Li explained that his earlier, general opinion applies to the Kriegs as end users. But the Kriegs do not point to anywhere in the record that shows that Justin Krieg did not know, or forgot, to thread the shoulder straps through the seatback. Thus, any specific opinions as to Justin Krieg's subjective experience are not based on a reliable application of reliable principles to the facts of the case.
The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Li's opinion on why customers may fail to use the shoulder straps is based on sufficient facts that fit this case. But Li may not speculate as to the Kriegs' subjective thoughts or knowledge.
5. Li's causation opinion is based on sufficient facts and data
Graco further argued that Li's opinions that different warnings may have changed the outcome of this case have no evidentiary or scientific foundation. Graco argued that foundation is lacking because (1) Li says only that changes "may have" prevented the incident and did no testing, and (2) the study he relies on does not fit this case.
Li's causation opinion is based on a study, the Blackler Study, that looked at individuals' interactions with manuals. That study did not involve children's products or swings, and its authors stated that its results "may not be generalizable across product types." Thus, Graco argued, this opinion is an analytical leap the Court should exclude.
Li also read case depositions, reviewed the product's instruction manual, and examined the product. He specifies that this opinion is "[b]ased on the Kriegs' depositions that they did not see the 'not safe for sleep' warnings." And he explained why the Blackler study could apply to juvenile products. The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Li's testimony is based on sufficient facts—relevant case evidence—and data—the Blacker study. The Court found that Li's causation opinion is more likely than not relevant and reliable.
6. Any risk that Li's testimony would mislead the jury does not substantially outweigh the testimony's probative value
Graco also argued that Li's testimony would mislead the jury. A court may exclude relevant evidence if the risk of misleading the jury substantially outweighs the evidence's probative value.
It should be noted that Graco did not cite to Rule 403 in moving to exclude any of Li's testimony or opinions. Graco also failed to show that any risk of misleading the jury substantially outweighs the evidence's probative value. The Court is unpersuaded that Li's testimony should be excluded under Rule 403.
D. Graco's motion to exclude certain expert testimony and opinions of Mannen, the Kriegs' biomechanical expert
The Kriegs designated Mannen to testify as to the swing's alleged design defect, how the swing's design may have contributed to R.K.'s death, and the Kriegs' proposed alternative design. Graco asked the Court to preclude Mannen from testifying or opining that (1) the swing's design could lead to respiratory issues; (2) a harness may not have prevented R.K.'s death; (3) the swing could lead to positional asphyxiation generally and in R.K.'s case; and (4) the swing's design would allow a child's face to come into contact with the swing's fabric, possibly leading to suffocation.
1. Mannen's failure to disclose the CPSC studies underlying her opinions on the swing's biomechanical properties does not render the opinions unreliable
Experts must disclose whatever data they considered in forming their opinions. This disclosure requirement avoids presenting "sketchy and vague" expert information.
Here, Mannen relied on studies she performed for the Consumer Product Safety Commission (“CPSC”). Graco has the studies' reports and attached them to its motion. But the Kriegs and Mannen have not disclosed what products were included in the CPSC studies, citing a confidentiality agreement. Still, Graco knows what types of products were included in the CPSC studies and that the DuetConnect was not part of either study. Graco argued that Mannen's opinions based on the CPSC studies should be excluded because the failure to disclose renders those opinions unverifiable. The Kriegs argued that Mannen isolated seat-back incline as a variable, removing other variables, so that the specific products used in the studies are largely irrelevant.
Mannen disclosed the data she considered in forming her opinions. And the Kriegs provided Graco with the underlying studies' reports. The specific products tested in the sleeper study were the only substantive information that was redacted. The seated-product report includes pictures and information on the products tested. This information is not "sketchy or vague."
Graco never moved to compel disclosure of the products used in the studies, arguably manufacturing prejudice for their Daubert motion. Graco can articulate several reasons why the studies may be questionable: neither the DuetConnect, nor any other baby swing; was included; the studies included children younger than R.K. was at death; and other variables that may have affected the underlying studies' results. So Graco has fodder to challenge the studies underlying Mannen's opinions on cross-examination.
The Kriegs explained that they redacted the products used in the CPSC studies because of a confidentiality agreement. The Kriegs cannot defeat a discovery order with a confidentiality agreement. But this Court never ordered disclosure of the products. So this factor does not weigh towards exclusion. Mannen's testimony is important because it goes to all three elements of the Kriegs' design-defect claim. This weighs against exclusion. If Mannen is allowed to testify, Graco can still challenge her opinions and their bases through the adversarial process. Thus, allowing the testimony will not prejudice Graco. This also weighs against exclusion. Finally, the Court will not grant a continuance to cure. The Court could still order disclosure before trial. But Graco has not moved to compel disclosure, so the issue of disclosure is not before the Court. The Court found that exclusion is not warranted on this basis.
2. Mannen's opinions on the swing's biomechanical properties are not unreliable
Graco further argued that Mannen failed to use the same scientific rigor in tests for this litigation. Mannen conducted "controlled testing with live infant subjects" for the CPSC studies but failed to conduct any live-infant testing for this litigation.
That a study used live children does not mean that all studies in the field must use live children. Mannen used the CPSC studies' results, peer-reviewed publications, and public CPSC reports in forming her opinions for this litigation. Any failure to conduct live testing for this case goes to the weight of the evidence rather than admissibility. The Kriegs have shown that Mannen's opinions are reliable by a preponderance of the evidence.
3. Mannen's opinion that shoulder straps would not have prevented this incident are not speculative
Mannen would opine that shoulder straps may not have prevented R.K.'s death because "infants can get out [the shoulder straps]." Graco argued this opinion should be excluded as speculative because Mannen did not analyze the swing's harness "or assess the circumstances or likelihood of R.K. escaping it."But Mannen stated in her deposition that she "observed the restraint system" and, with her juvenile-products experience, had enough information to come to her opinions. So the Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Mannen's opinion is based on sufficient facts and data.
4. Mannen's opinion that a safe alternative design would have a firm, flat surface is not irrelevant
Mannen would opine that a safer alternative design for the swing would incorporate a firm, flat surface, defining flat as less than a ten-degree incline. Graco argued that this opinion is irrelevant because a product with a firm, flat surface is more like a crib than a swing.
The DuetConnect's back had an incline greater than ten degrees. Mannen's opinion makes it more probable than not that a swing with a seatback of ten degrees or less would be safer. So this opinion is relevant. A material fact is one of consequence in determining the action.A safer alternative design is a required element of the Kriegs' design-defect claim. So this testimony is material. The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that this opinion will help the jury resolve whether the Kriegs' proposed alternative design would be safer.
5. The Kriegs state that Mannen will not offer any opinions about the product's concavity or facial contact with the product's soft goods
Graco argued that the Court should preclude Mannen from opining that the swing's design makes it easier for the faces of unharnessed children to come into contact with the swing's fabric. Graco stated that this opinion is irrelevant. But the Kriegs stated that "Mannen will not offer any opinions at trial regarding the concavity of the product and potential contact with the soft goods, nor that R.K. rolled from a supine to prone position." The Court agreed with the Kriegs that this fact renders Graco's argument against these opinions moot.
The Court denied Graco's motion to exclude certain testimony and opinions by Mannen.
E. Graco's motion to exclude certain expert testimony and opinions of Singhose, the Kriegs' mechanical-engineering expert
The Kriegs designated Singhose to testify about "the design of the product and the hazards that it presents." Graco asked the Court to preclude Singhose from testifying or opining (1) that the swing's cantilever design is defective and unreasonably dangerous; (2) that the swing's design was a producing cause of R.K.'s death; (3) that an A-frame would be a safer alternative design; (4) that R.K. may have been able to move out of the swing's shoulder straps; and (5) why consumers like the Kriegs may not know how to use the shoulder straps because of the swing's assembly manual.
1. Singhose's causation opinion is relevant
Singhose would opine that the swing's design contributed to R.K.'s death. Graco argued that the causation opinion is irrelevant because Singhose admitted that the incident would not have occurred had R.K. been secured with the harness system.
An undisputed fact here is that R.K. was not secured with the shoulder straps. So Singhose's testimony, based on R.K. not wearing the shoulder straps, fits these facts. Singhose's opinion offered an explanation for why R.K. moved into the position that the Kriegs believe caused his death. Whether the design was a producing cause of R.K.'s death is at issue. So, his design opinion is relevant to a material fact under Rule 401.
Graco further argued that Singhose did not analyze the effect of "deflection" on the incident. It also argued that Singhose's deflection opinions did not fit these facts. According to Singhose, deflection is a byproduct of the swing's cantilever design. Singhose explained that the swing's structure will "bend downward to the right."He stated that this "downward deflection" "contributes to the baby moving out of a safe position." Graco complained of Singhose's failure to "assess how far forward R.K. needed to have leaned" to cause the incident. It also complained of Singhose's failure to conduct testing to determine whether reducing deflection would have affected R.K.'s ability to get into the position that caused his death. An expert's opinion must reflect a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts of the case.
Singhose looked at the effect of deflection based on engineering principles. He applied these principles to the swing's structure. Any issues that Graco has with Singhose's testing goes to the weight of the evidence and can be raised on cross-examination. The Kriegs have proved by a preponderance of the evidence that Singhose's design-defect testimony is relevant and reliable.
2. Singhose's causation opinion is reliable
Graco argued that Singhose cannot reliably opine that alleged design defects were a substantial factor in causing R.K.'s death. Yet the testing, standards, and publication factors set forth in Daubert—the only factors the parties discuss—weigh in favor of finding the opinion reliable. Singhose tested the effect of weight and movement on the swing's cantilever design and seat incline. To replicate the case's known facts, he did not use the shoulder straps. By conducting testing without the shoulder straps, Singhose reliably applied these testing methods to the facts of the case. Plus, industry standards are intended to cover foreseeable misuse. Singhose's methods for this litigation mirror methods he used in peer-reviewed publications. This does not validate Singhose's opinion. But it does corroborate its underlying methodology. Weighing an expert's reliability is in a district court's discretion. This Court did not find that Singhose's opinion so lacking. The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Singhose's causation opinions are reliable.
3. Singhose's alternative-design opinion is reliable
Graco also argued that Singhose cannot reliably opine about the Kriegs' proposed alternative design, which incorporates an A-frame, because he did not test such swings. But Singhose's opinion can be tested and is the product of engineering principles. Singhose's report contrasts the load-bearing abilities of end-supported structures, such as A-frames, to cantilever-design structures. He concluded that an "end-supported beam can rigidly, and safely, hold a wide variety of loads." He cited "Mark's Standard Handbook for Mathematical Engineers." These engineering principles support his opinion that an A-frame, which would be more stable, would be a safer alternative design to the cantilever design. The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that Singhose's alternative-design opinion is reliable.
4. Singhose's opinion that children can get out of the shoulder straps is the product of reliable methodology
Graco argued that Singhose's testimony "that R.K. may been able to wiggle out of his shoulder restraints is not the product of reliable methodology." It claimed that this testimony is unreliable because it is only based on his personal experience with his own children and car seats. But Singhose also bases his opinion on product reviews and his comparative analysis between the swing's five-point harness and that of a car seat. According to Singhose, collecting and analyzing online reviews is a "commonly-used method to obtain information about the design of a product." Graco replied that "the online product reviews do not support Singhose's opinion." But it does not challenge analyzing reviews as a reliable methodology. The Kriegs have shown by a preponderance of the evidence that this opinion is the product of reliable methodology.
5. Singhose's testimony that the assembly instructions are difficult to follow is not cumulative
Graco argued in its reply that the Court should exclude Singhose's testimony on the difficulty of following the assembly instructions because it is cumulative. It argued that Li, another of the Kriegs' experts, will also testify as to the assembly instructions' difficulty. But Singhose pairs his assembly-instruction opinion with a design opinion, stating that the product's design made some of the steps "difficult to perform." Li's opinion is from a human-factors perspective, discussing how consumers interact with products and their instructions. So the opinion is neither needlessly cumulative nor merely repetitious.
6. Singhose's testimony that the assembly instructions are difficult to follow is not outside his expertise
Finally, Graco argued that "Singhose's warning opinions should also be excluded as ... outside his area of expertise." An expert generally may not testify beyond the scope of his expertise. Singhose's expertise is in juvenile products, including their design. Specifically, he has conducted human testing and observed that "ways in which humans do not use products exactly as the designers intend."
Assembly instructions bridge how consumers interact with products. Thus, Singhose's opinions that the assembly instructions were difficult to follow is not outside his expertise.
The Court denied Graco's motion to exclude certain opinions and testimony by Singhose.
Held
The Court found that Graco's motion to exclude testimony by Wayne Li should be granted in part as follows: Li may not speculate as to the Kriegs' subjective thoughts or knowledge. In all other respects, the parties' motions to exclude expert testimony were denied.
Key Takeaway
Proof of causation requires more than conjecture or guess. But a Court need only find that an opinion is reliable, not that it is correct. Reliability does not require certainty. In fact, "there is always some degree of uncertainty when a litigant seeks to establish causation by expert testimony."
Case Details:
Case Caption: | Krieg v. Graco Children's Products |
|---|---|
Docket Number: | 6:24cv171 |
Court Name: | United States District Court for the Western District of Texas, Waco Division |
Order Date: | November 09, 2026 |




