Healthcare Industry Expert Allowed to Opine on Physician Recruiting Practices
Posted on November 19, 2026 by Shuva Guha Thakurta
This action arises from the involvement of Todd Kruger, the former General Counsel of CCMC, in a Qui Tam action filed against Plaintiffs. Defendants sought to exclude the testimony of Plaintiffs' expert witnesses, Autumn Warden and James Carroll.

Healthcare Industry Expert Witness
Autumn E. Warden, MPA, received both a bachelor’s degree in healthcare administration and a Master of Public Administration with a focus on nonprofit management from Ohio University. A seasoned veteran of the health care industry, Warden has unique experience in physician compensation practices, policies, and applicable laws, as well as physician recruitment.
Warden is also a fact witness and current employee of the Plaintiff, Marietta Memorial Hospital. She has not been retained or specifically employed to provide expert testimony, nor do her duties regularly involve giving expert testimony.
Accounting Expert Witness
James Carroll, CPA/CFF, CFE, CRMA, MBA, MS has over twenty (20) years of experience, with expertise in fraud and forensic accounting investigations, forensic accounting analyses, financial investigations of embezzlement and white-collar crime, forensic accounting analyses and damage quantification for class action disputes, post-acquisition disputes, and economic damage quantification.
Discussion by the Court
Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Carroll
Carroll is an eminently qualified forensic accounting expert. He is the only expert in this case who is a forensic accountant, or even a CPA. Indeed, many of the critiques emerge from purported experts who concede they did not even read Carroll's report, let alone understand it.
While Defendants attempt to shift the field of Carroll's offered expertise, accusing him of offering opinions on healthcare operations, physician recruitment, and patient demand modeling, his testimony is not in those areas. Carroll's opinions are exclusively within the field of forensic accounting and damages.
Defendants complained that Carroll has no experience in healthcare operations, physician recruitment, and patient demand modeling; however, he is not testifying as to causation or liability. His calculations are based upon the damages if the jury were to find Defendants liable. Requiring the witness to be experienced in healthcare operations is akin to having a damages expert in an automobile accident case to be an auto mechanic or accident reconstruction witness.
Carroll detailed his precise methodology and employed standard principles throughout his report. Carroll's methodology proceeds broadly in six (6) clearly defined steps, each grounded in actual Marietta records, the leading industry benchmarks, and transparent reasonable assumptions. At a high level, he first identified all physician positions opened during the relevant period. Second, he determined the actual number of days each position took to fill. Third, he established the industry benchmark, the expected days to fill, using the Association for Advancing Physician and Provider Recruitment ("AAPPR") data tailored to Marietta's specific characteristics. Fourth, he calculated the excess days by subtracting the benchmark from the actual days. Fifth, he determined the revenue lost per day for each unfilled position using Marietta's own financial records. Sixth, he multiplied excess days by per-day lost revenue to arrive at total damages. He utilized two (2) different scenarios, fully explained in his report, and provided his conclusion.
Each step is transparent, verifiable, and grounded in objective data. There is no speculation. Defendants and their experts can challenge any input, question any assumption, and present their own calculations to the jury. That is what cross-examination and competing experts are for. It is not a basis for exclusion.
Furthermore, despite criticizing Carroll's methodology, Defendants' experts confirmed every foundational choice he made. Indeed, neither the motion nor their experts identify an actual methodological flaw or better data source that should have been utilized, and the experts concede many of the flaws in the alternative approaches offered by Defendants. This does not justify exclusion.
Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Warden
Defendants sought to exclude Warden's testimony in two (2) areas. First, they sought to exclude Warden's opinion that the federal government's investigation related to the underlying Qui Tam against Plaintiffs negatively impacted Plaintiffs' physician recruitment and retention. Second, they sought to exclude her opinion that the Qui Tam relators, Michael King and Michael Roberts, did not have a good faith or reasonable basis to claim that Plaintiffs had violated Stark Act or "anti-kickback" laws that formed the basis of the underlying Qui Tam action.
As clarified by Plaintiffs, Warden's opinions stem from her expertise to opine on both the impact of the Department of Justice ("DOJ") investigation on physician recruiting and retention (i.e. physician recruitment); and on how Marietta's compensation policies (specifically those detailed in the Qui Tam) met industry and regulatory standards, such that Defendants lacked an objective reasonable or good faith basis to make allegations of wrongdoing (i.e. physician compensation valuation).
With respect to her qualifications, Warden is the Senior Director for Business Development & Physician Alignment at Memorial Health System. Prior to that role, she has spent the past decade employed by Marietta in various roles related to physician recruitment and compensation. Given this, her testimony is central to this case. First, the allegations in the Qui Tam related to precisely her area of expertise in her day-to-day job of physician compensation, recruitment, and compliance with key federal laws such as the Stark Law and the Anti-Kickback Statute—her knowledge is therefore relevant, consequential, and critically helpful to the jury in understanding the facts of this case. Second, she was intimately involved in observing the impact of the DOJ investigation on the hospital and on her ability to recruit and retain physicians and has first-hand observations which inform her understanding of the impacts of the investigation. Third, she was extensively involved in Plaintiffs' time-consuming and burdensome response to the DOJ investigation. Finally, as an expert in physician recruitment and compensation, and along with her status as a national leader in the field, she can provide well-supported, well-reasoned opinions on the Qui Tam, its impact, and physician recruiting and compensation.
Warden's proposed expert testimony is limited to her precise area of expertise. She offered no opinions on the False Claims Act or legal conclusions on ultimate issues, and as explained in the disclosure, offered no testimony "with respect to the specific dollar value or calculation of any monetary damages claimed," as she is not the "damages" witness.
Most of what Defendants challenge in their motion is Warden's testimony about what she personally observed, experienced, and did in her capacity as Marietta's chief physician recruiter, and as part of the response to the DOJ investigation. That is fact testimony and opinion testimony under Rule 701. A Daubert motion is the wrong vehicle to challenge it. Defendants cannot invoke Rule 702's gatekeeping framework to exclude testimony that is not subject to those requirements in the first place.
At a high level, Warden would help to educate the jury about the field and practice of physician recruitment and compensation, including the necessity of compliance with the key federal statutes, and how professionals seek to do so. This testimony appears to be unchallenged by the Motion. Beyond this, she plans to offer two (2) primary opinions that fall under Rule 702, each of which is well supported, reliable, and helpful to the jury:
First, Warden will testify about physician recruiting practices, the types of factors that affect a physician's decision-making during the recruitment process, that a federal investigation would be expected to negatively affect a physician recruit's decision, and that, in the aggregate, the federal investigation negatively affected plaintiffs' physician recruitment and retention.
Second, Warden would testify that based on her experience, industry standards, her first-hand knowledge, her study of company materials, and the nature of physician compensation, that (a) Marietta's compensation policies (specifically those detailed in the Qui Tam) met industry and regulatory standards, and (b) Defendants could not have had an objective reasonable or good faith basis to make the allegations of wrongdoing.
To the extent Defendants take issue with any aspect of these, the only issues raised are matters for cross-examination, and not anything that impacts the admissibility of the testimony.
Held
The Court denied the Defendants' motions to exclude Autumn Ward's and James Carroll's opinions.
Key Takeaway
In assessing a proffered expert's qualifications, courts must "'consider the proposed expert's full range of experience and training,' not just his professional qualifications." Once qualified, an expert's testimony is admissible if it will assist the trier of fact and is (1) "based on sufficient facts or data," (2) "the product of reliable principles and methods," and (3) "the principles and methods [have been applied] reliably to the facts of the case."
Case Details:
Case Caption: | Marietta Area Healthcare V. Camden-Clark Memorial Hospital Corporation |
|---|---|
Docket Number: | 5:23cv131 |
Court Name: | United States District Court for the Northern District of West Virginia |
Order Date: | June 18, 2026 |




