Transportation Expert's Failure-To-Train Testimony Limited

Posted on November 17, 2026 by Shuva Guha Thakurta

This case arises from a motor vehicle collision that occurred near Trinidad, Colorado. According to Plaintiffs, Defendant Colangelo was operating a tow truck and struck Plaintiffs' car as he attempted to maneuver past their vehicle from behind. In their Complaint, Plaintiffs asserted various claims under Colorado law against Colangelo and J.M. Tire Inc., the owner of the tow truck.

Plaintiffs retained Linda L. Day to provide opinions on general commercial motor vehicle (CMV) industry standards and practices; Defendant J.M. Tire's motor carrier management failures; Defendant Colangelo's CMV operating failures; and preventability analysis under recognized industry standards. Defendants sought to exclude Day, arguing "the only factual basis for her opinions was the occurrence of the collision" itself.

Transportation Expert's Failure-To-Train Testimony Limited

Transportation Expert Witness

Linda Lucille Day has been in the transportation and warehousing industry since 1984, received her CDL in 1995 with endorsements for hazardous materials, tankers, double and triple trailers, school buses, and passenger buses, and drove over-the-road for more than ten years, working both as a company driver and owner-operator and as a driver trainer.

Get the full story on challenges to Linda Lucille Day's expert opinions and testimony with an in-depth Challenge Study.

Discussion by the Court

Defendants directed the Court to two district court decisions where Day's opinions were excluded as not sufficiently tied to the facts. The Court found that most of Day's opinions are similar here. Many of Day's opinions are generalities as to what truck drivers should do and be trained to do to avoid accidents." These opinions are too general to help the jury.

Second, the Court agreed with Plaintiffs that Day's opinions about J.M.'s failure to train are based on case-specific facts. But the problem is her conclusions that the failure to train either caused the accident ( "J.M. Tire and Defendant Colangelo are responsible for this accident occurring."), or that adequate training would have prevented this accident from occurring, are based merely on the fact the accident occurred. This is confirmed by Day's deposition testimony. For example, when Day testified she believes that if Colangelo had better training he "would have had a better understanding of the space around his vehicle, and this accident most likely would not have occurred," she doesn't rely on any case-specific facts that suggest Colangelo lacked an understanding of the space around his vehicle, other than that the accident occurred. This example is in addition to those cited in the Motion, where Day concedes her opinions that Defendants failed to comply with industry standards are based on the accident having occurred. There is no methodology supporting these opinions. These opinions, therefore, do not reflect a reliable application of principles and methods to the facts.

But the Court did find one of Day's opinions sufficiently reliable, helpful to the trier of fact, and based on case-specific facts. This is her opinion of J.M.'s failure to train concerning its vehicles qualifying as emergency vehicles. This opinion is relevant because a jury could reasonably infer that Colangelo's conduct or decision-making leading to the accident was improperly influenced by his incorrect belief that he drove an emergency vehicle; a belief he had because that's what J.M. trained him to believe.

Held

The Court granted in part and denied in part the Defendant's motion to exclude the testimony of Linda Day. The only testimony Day may provide concerns the failure to train (or mistraining) regarding emergency vehicles.

Key Takeaway

The decision to admit or exclude expert testimony is committed to the sound discretion of the district court.

Case Details:

Case Caption:

Garmany V. Colangelo

Docket Number:

1:24cv663

Court Name:

United States District Court for the District of Colorado

Order Date:

November 11, 2026