Occupational Medicine Expert’s Opinions on Future Injections, Surgery, and Pain Management Admitted
Posted on November 16, 2026 by Shuva Guha Thakurta
This action arises from a motor vehicle collision that occurred on March 1, 2023, between Defendant Antonio Wortham and Plaintiff Radha Bolivar. Plaintiff Bolivar had one passenger in his vehicle, Plaintiff Angelica Goatache. Plaintiffs sought damages for "past, current and future economic and non-economic damages."
Plaintiffs retained Dr. Gregory L. Smith—a medical doctor and life care planner—as an expert. Smith provided an expert report and life care plan, which estimates future medical costs for Bolivar. As the basis for his opinions, Smith stated that he reviewed Bolivar's medical records, which included records from his treating physicians. He also conducted an interview with Bolivar.
Defendants disclosed Dr. Joseph Schaffer—an orthopedic shoulder surgeon—as an expert. Schaffer reviewed video footage of the accident and opines that he does not believe the accident caused Bolivar's shoulder injury based on his knowledge of shoulder injuries, understanding of energy from his engineering degree, and training in sports medicine.

Occupational Medicine Expert Witness
Dr. Gregory Luke Smith, M.D., M.P.H., C.L.C.P. is residency-trained and board-certified in Occupational Medicine. He has over 30 years of clinical practice treating injuries. He has over 20 years of experience using evidence-based medical (EBM) nationally recognized treatment guidelines to pre-certify the treatment and rehabilitation of injuries for various insurance companies. He has written scores of Life Care Plans and Medical Cost Analyses discussing future medical care issues and is certified in Medical Cost Analysis.
Orthopedic Surgery Expert Witness
Joseph C. Schaffer, MD, is a fellowship-trained, board-certified orthopedic surgeon specializing in the diagnosis and treatment of sports-related injuries and other disorders of the shoulder, knee, and elbow. He is board-certified by the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery.
Discussion by the Court
Gregory Smith
Smith’s expert report disclosed that he believes, based on Bolivar’s “clinical records and information provided,” that (1) Bolivar has “ongoing issues with left shoulder internal derangement, cervical and lumbar herniated disc that will require interventional pain injections, and/or surgery”; (2) his “chronic pain . . . will benefit from prolonged use of a neuromuscular stimulator”; and (3) his “reported symptoms of anxiety, depression, insomnia and fear/avoidance behaviors . . . need to be evaluated and treated.” Defendants argued that Smith is not qualified, that his testimony is not supported by sufficient facts or data, and that his methods are not reliable.
Smith is board-certified in occupational medicine with over 30 years of clinical practice treating injuries. His training as a doctor, along with his experience with injuries, makes him qualified to analyze the future medical care Bolivar may need as a result of a motor vehicle accident.
His expert report relies on sufficient facts and data. Specifically, he reviewed medical records from several of Bolivar's treating physicians and conducted a phone interview with Bolivar.
Defendant argued that Smith's methods are not reliable because he does "not focus on the specific facts of the case but rather provides an average for an abstract, unspecified individual." However, Smith's report stated he reviewed specific information about Bolivar to come to his conclusions, and whether his opinions are ultimately too abstract is more appropriately determined by a jury after cross-examination.
Defendants disagreed with Smith's conclusions and claimed that it contradicted other individuals' testimonies about Bolivar's future needs. However, during Smith’s phone interview with Bolivar, Bolivar complained that he “continues to have ongoing mechanical left shoulder, neck, and low back pain that is associated with stiffness and decreased range of motion . . . .” Although Smith’s conclusions may differ from other individuals’ opinions about the scope of Bolivar’s injuries and his future medical needs, the Court found that his conclusions have some basis in facts and data specific to Bolivar. Defendants’ arguments go to the weight of Smith’s testimony, not the admissibility.
Joseph Schaffer
Schaffer plans to testify on "Bolivar's alleged injuries, complaints, and limitations and whether or not they are causally related to the March 1, 2023 incident." One of Schaffer's opinions is that he does not believe Bolivar's shoulder injury was caused by the accident based on his analysis of Bolivar's medical records and video of the accident.
Plaintiffs "did not challenge Schaffer's qualifications as an orthopedic shoulder surgeon" but argued that he is not qualified to provide an opinion: (1) regarding Bolivar's spine and (2) interpreting video of the accident. Plaintiffs argued that Schaffer's video analysis lacks technical foundation and may not supplant the jury's exercise of common sense. Defendants countered that Schaffer's clinical practice includes evaluating patients for back pain, and that his use of the video was only one piece of information that helped him form his opinion. Defendants also state that Schaffer is qualified in observing "injuries as they occur and evaluating whether the mechanism of an event is consistent with the alleged injuries."
The Court held that Schaffer's experience and training as a medical doctor make him qualified to opine on Bolivar's injuries, including his alleged back injuries. Further, his use of the accident video is not outside the scope of his expertise, nor does it supplant the jury's exercise of common sense. Rather, Schaffer stated that he formed his opinion based on the video in conjunction with his knowledge of how shoulders work and when Bolivar's symptoms and pain developed. During his deposition, Schaffer testified that his experience as a shoulder surgeon and his history of observing injuries as they occur in sporting events provide him with knowledge on how injuries may present after an accident. Schaffer's opinion, which is partially based on video evidence, will not supplant the jury's exercise of common sense, because he has specialized knowledge on shoulder injuries and how such injuries can present. Similar to Defendants' argument to exclude Smith, Plaintiffs' arguments go to the weight of Schaffer's testimony and not its admissibility.
Held
The Court denied Plaintiffs' motion to exclude Dr. Joseph Schaffer and Defendants' motion to exclude Dr. Gregory Smith.
The jury returned a verdict in favor of Defendants HMD Trucking, Inc. and Antonio Wortham, and Plaintiffs Radha Bolivar and Angelica Goatache were awarded no damages. The case was closed.
Key Takeaway
While a court's role is to determine whether an expert's testimony is reliable, not whether it is accurate or credible, a court must still determine that an expert's opinion rests on a "reliable foundation" rather than "unsupported speculation."
Case Details:
Case Caption: | Bolivar V. HMD Trucking Inc. |
|---|---|
Docket Number: | 1:24cv155 |
Court Name: | United States District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee |
Order Date: | June 16, 2026 |




