Geology Expert Allowed to Opine on Asbestos Identification

Posted on November 16, 2026 by Shuva Guha Thakurta

In this action, Plaintiff Andrew Curtin, individually and as personal representative of the estate of his late spouse, Cynthia Cartwright, alleged that Cartwright’s death from mesothelioma occurred as a result of her long-term use of Johnson & Johnson Baby Powder ("JBP").

Defendants asked the Court to exclude the opinions of Plaintiff’s experts, John J. Godleski, Sean Fitzgerald, and David B. Madigan, while Plaintiff filed a motion to exclude the testimony of Defendants’ expert witness, Matthew S. Sanchez.

Geology Expert Allowed to Opine on Asbestos Identification

Pathology Expert Witness

John Joseph Godleski was on the faculty of Harvard Medical School (HMS), Brigham and Women’s Hospital (BWH), and Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH) from 1978-2017, retiring as Professor of Pathology in 2017 and named Professor of Pathology. Emeritus in 2018. Godleski graduated from the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine.

Get the full story on challenges to John Godleski’s expert opinions and testimony with an in-depth Challenge Study.

Geology Expert Witnesses

Dr. Matthew Spencer Sanchez is a trained geologist with an emphasis in mineralogy; he has earned a B.S., M.A., and Ph.D. in the field; and for the past 16 years, he has dedicated himself to studying asbestos in raw materials and mine and quarry sites.

Want to know more about the challenges Matthew Sanchez has faced? Get the full details with our Challenge Study report.

Sean Fitzgerald is a licensed Professional Geologist, mineralogist, and asbestos expert, with over 30 years of experience analyzing asbestos minerals and researching and developing the science of asbestos.

Discover more cases with Sean Fitzgerald as an expert witness by ordering his comprehensive Expert Witness Profile report.

Statistics Expert Witness

David Bennett Madigan received his bachelor's degree in mathematics (1984, First Class Honours, Gold Medal) and a Ph.D. in statistics (1990), both from Trinity College Dublin. He is also an epidemiologist and an expert in epidemiology. Madigan is credited with more than 200 publications in such areas as Bayesian statistics, text mining, Monte Carlo methods, pharmacovigilance, and probabilistic graphical models. He is an elected fellow of the American Statistical Association, the Institute of Mathematical Statistics, and the American Association for the Advancement of Science. 

Get the full story on challenges to David Madigan’s expert opinions and testimony with an in-depth Challenge Study.

Discussion by the Court

A. Defendants' Motion In Limine To Exclude The Opinions Of Dr. John Godleski

Godleski's opinions are informed by his education and experience and by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray analyses (EDX) that he employed to study histologic slides and paraffin tissue blocks taken from Cartwright's diseased lung tissue. He is prepared to describe pathology findings in Cartwright's treatment history, including the diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma, biphasic subtype (also described as malignant spindle cell neoplasm most consistent with malignant mesothelioma, sarcomatoid type).

Godleski's study of the slides did not disclose the presence of asbestos bodies but did disclose the presence of talc particles. Given the minuteness of the specimen available for examination, and extrapolating that the presence of talc "would . . . likely . . . be found in any section of this lung tissue," Godleski's opined that the evidence "is indicative of substantial talc exposure." He also propounds: "Although no asbestos bodies or asbestos fibers were found within this minuscule amount of tissue, the finding of talc strongly indicates that asbestos was also likely to be present in [Ms. Cartwright's] lung tissue and pleural space."

Despite the non-detection of asbestos bodies or fibers in the available samples, Godleski maintains that the presence of talc particles is consistent not only with substantial talc exposure but also with asbestos inhalation.

In effect, Godleski relied on his experience and training to draw an inference of significant asbestos exposure based on evidence of significant talc inhalation.

Defendant requested that Godleski be prohibited from testifying on the subject of causation. Defendant states that a causation expert would be expected to testify that asbestos was present in the lung tissue in excess of background levels. Given that Godleski was unable to detect asbestos in the limited available samples, Defendant argued that Godleski's projection about the probable presence of asbestos does not rely on any reliable "methodology or legitimate science." Defendant quoted Godleski's deposition testimony, in which he acknowledged that given the non-detection of asbestos bodies or fibers in the available samples, he could not reliably extrapolate the load of asbestos fibers in Ms. Cartwright's lung tissue through application of a scientific methodology.

In opposition to the motion to exclude, Plaintiff argued that the mesothelioma diagnosis, which is undisputed, sets the stage for a finding of significant asbestos inhalation given Cartwright's history. Additionally, Plaintiff explained that peer-reviewed literature, with which Godleski is conversant, establishes the presence of asbestos in Johnson Baby Powder (JBP), a product that Ms. Cartwright is known to have utilized throughout her adult life. Based on these building blocks, Plaintiff argued that positive samples are not essential to prove causation, and that it is reasonable for an expert such as Godleski to formulate an opinion that asbestos contamination from JBP is the most likely explanation for Cartwright's development of mesothelioma.

Based on the Court's review and understanding of the record in this case, including Ms. Cartwright's personal history of long-term use of JBP, the strong association between mesothelioma and asbestos exposure, Godleski's asserted finding of significant evidence of talc inhalation, and the underlying controversy over the existence of asbestos contamination in JBP, the Court is not convinced that Godleski's opinion on causation is subject to exclusion. The Court's conclusion is based on the helpfulness of Godleski's specialized knowledge in pathology and his findings upon scientific examination, his incorporation and analysis of the available facts and data that inform this particular case, his use of reliable principles and methods to detect evidence of significant talc inhalation, and his correlation of what he considers to be the most salient information, specialized knowledge, and existing principles and methods in support of an opinion that the fact finder could regard as one reliable basis to support a finding that Ms. Cartwright's mesothelioma was caused by asbestos that traveled to her lungs most likely in connection with talc inhalation. To be sure, Defendant's challenge may well erode Godleski's credibility and deprive his opinion of weight in the mind of the fact finder. But assuming that the case presented by Plaintiff is otherwise demonstrative of asbestos contamination in JBP, the exclusion of Godleski's causation opinion would subject his opinion to a more demanding standard than proof by a preponderance of the evidence. This motion is therefore denied.

D. Plaintiff's Motion To Exclude Expert Testimony Of Dr. Matthew Sanchez

Matthew Sanchez is one of Defendants' expert witnesses. Sanchez acknowledged that asbestos can be present in both talc deposits and in finished talc products. But Plaintiff insisted that Sanchez's testimony must be excluded because the methodology he uses to detect asbestos in powdered talc products is antiquated and he has refused to keep up with recent developments in asbestos detection standards. Additionally, in a different case, Sanchez was set up at a deposition to opine whether specific laboratory images (photomicrographs) of isolated asbestos in fact depicted asbestos, and he demurred. The Asbestos Plaintiffs' bar in this case and others has argued that the combination of these two things requires courts to remove Sanchez from cases involving alleged talcum powder asbestos exposure.

Defendants described Sanchez as their mineralogy, geology, and microscopy expert. They responded that his views are concededly based on a methodology and that "disagreements in the literature do not render a recognized methodology unreliable."

Based on the Court's review of the arguments and the cited literature, which includes a variety of regulatory material, including a proposed agency rule that was recently withdrawn based in part on the complexity of asbestos testing, the Court is persuaded by Defendants that Sanchez's approach to asbestos detection employs a reliable standard for the microscopic detection of asbestos even if that standard is exceedingly demanding in relation to the identification of asbestos or of limited precision in the talcum powder context. The alleged demanding nature or limited precision of Sanchez's methodology can be addressed in cross-examination. Plaintiff can also inquire of Sanchez concerning the fact that the Food and Drug Administration once propounded the increased utility of a supplemental asbestos detection methodology for powdered cosmetic talc. The presentation of all of this scientific information will prove helpful to the jury.

C. Defendants' Motion To Exclude Expert Opinions Of Sean Fitzgerald

Fitzgerald's opinions are classified as a contamination opinion, in which he opines that the JBP Cartwright used included asbestos, and an exposure opinion, in which he opines that Cartwright was exposed to asbestos through her use of JBP because the asbestos becomes airborne, and that her exposure would be significant based on her alleged decades of use.

Fitzgerald reports positive identification of asbestos in eight bottles of JBP but has also conceded that he failed to detect asbestos in other samples. As for his alleged positive findings, Defendants asserted that Fitzgerald cannot produce some of the underlying data because it has been lost. As for his negative findings, Fitzgerald has preserved none of the underlying data at all. Defendants complained that they are prejudiced in their ability to cross-examine Fitzgerald because they cannot reliably evaluate the data that informs Fitzgerald's opinions. They also argued that Fitzgerald should not be heard by the jury because his methods of examination were unreliable and are not generally accepted. Defendants also argued that Fitzgerald should not be permitted to testify in a way that imports the contamination opinions of a specific, non-testifying expert, Dr. William Longo.

1. Contamination Concern

a. Relevance of sample sets

Defendants challenged the relevance of the JBP samples from which Fitzgerald reports making positive asbestos findings. Based on Defendants' account of the source mine concern, i.e., that the degree of asbestos contamination of one mine or one ore deposit will not be identical to that of another, Plaintiff's challenge is to reassure the Court that Fitzgerald's findings have relevance to Cartwright's JBP use and, moreover, provide reliable grounds on which to base a finding concerning the likely existence of asbestos contamination in the JBP bottles used by Cartwright during her lifetime.

Based on the Court's review of Plaintiff's opposition, Fitzgerald found asbestos in JBP samples taken from an expansive period of time, spanning dates before, during, and after the period of Cartwright's use (whether that use is measured as starting in either the 1960s or the 1970s). His tests offer a reliable basis for concluding that, regardless of time period or source mine, and consistent with Fitzgerald's geology and mineralogy lessons concerning the phased formulation of solid solution magnesium silicates, it is to be anticipated that JBP, being produced from talc ore, will be contaminated to varying degrees with amphibole and serpentine mineral deposits in their asbestiform habits. While it is possible and has been demonstrated that a given sample may not be contaminated with asbestos, the opinion evidence and the principles and methodologies it is based on permit a finding that it is probable (rather than merely possible) that some subset of samples will contain asbestos, that contamination with asbestos will occur with a degree of regularity, and that the contamination will involve a variety of asbestos minerals in varying concentrations. Thus, even for test results drawn from samples having an origin outside of the "relevant" time period, reliable lessons are available, and the jury will no doubt understand and appreciate that contaminated samples taken from JBP sourced from different mines and different time periods are not direct proof that the JBP used by Cartwright was contaminated with the same asbestiform mineral in the same degree. The jury can take that into account as a matter of weight when engaged in deliberations concerning the probability of significant contamination occurring over multiple decades of use.

b. Underlying data

Defendants challenged the fairness of allowing Fitzgerald to express an opinion about tests he performed, asserting that he failed to preserve the data on which he relied, such as supporting images, and totally failed to preserve any information concerning negative results. The Court concluded that this challenge also goes to weight rather than admissibility. Based on Plaintiff's opposition, Fitzgerald disclosed data associated with his positive findings. Additionally, concerning his negative findings, the jury will learn that Fitzgerald has conducted tests of JBP samples that were negative for the presence of asbestos. Although it appears that Fitzgerald has failed to preserve data associated with his negative findings—though he has recovered some in connection with this motion process— Fitzgerald's positive findings are not rendered unreliable by his failure to prove his negative findings. Incidentally, the acknowledgment of negative test results reveals that the TEM methodology does not guarantee false positives.

c. Chain of custody/authenticity

Defendants challenged the fairness of allowing Fitzgerald to express an opinion about tests he performed with JBP bottles having unknown origins and chains of custody. The Court concluded that the record can support a finding that the samples are what they are purported to be. The samples were drawn from product encapsulated in tamper-proof packaging. There is no apparent reason to suspect malfeasance or that the mineral composition of the packages' contents would change over time. Under the circumstances, given the packaging and contents involved, there is no cause to preclude the evidence as inherently unreliable or to superimpose demanding chain-of-custody requirements. The jury could but would not be required to conclude that an expert in the field would reasonably rely on these samples as data in support of an opinion.

d. Methodology

Defendants challenged the fairness of allowing Fitzgerald to express an opinion about asbestos identification, arguing that his use of transmission electron microscopy (TEM) departs from accepted standards in a manner that they say is known to produce false positive findings. The Court found that this argument (including its protestations related to the Yamate protocols) presents only a matter of the weight to be assigned to Fitzgerald's methodology. In effect, this part of Defendants' motion is the mirror image of Plaintiff's motion to exclude Sanchez's opinion based on an allegedly unreliable methodology. The opposing geology and mineralogy experts are, in effect, at odds about the best approach for identifying asbestos in powdered talc and the reliability of the new approach involving TEM and related standards. But they are employing scientific methodologies on both sides. Fitzgerald's utilization of TEM and the associated regulatory standards is reliable, fits the case, and should prove helpful to the jury, even if the jury ultimately is not persuaded by Fitzgerald's methodology and the associated findings.

2. Exposure Concern

Defendants raised two challenges to Fitzgerald's opinion that Cartwright "was exposed to significant airborne asbestos." The first is based on the relevance of the samples and the chain-of-custody concern. The Court has already concluded that these arguments do not warrant exclusion. The second argument is that the "glovebox" test is unreliable. As Defendants see it, powdering a baby doll in a confined space is not representative of Cartwright's alleged exposure, which consisted of powdering her shoes in a more open space. They observed that, by artificially confining the volume of air, the resulting asbestos concentration readings do not fit the circumstances of this case.

Plaintiff argued that the tests are a proper means of demonstrating exposure via inhalation and that Fitzgerald did not intend to offer any opinion about exposure concentration; only that asbestos is released into the air and becomes breathable. Based on the Court's review of the paper, "Asbestos in Commercial Cosmetic Talcum Powder as a Cause of Mesothelioma in Women," published in the International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health, with its depiction of air intakes at face height, the test appears in the Court's judgment to be both reliable and fit to demonstrate inhalation risk based on common application of powder below the level of the user's breathing zone (rather than above the face in the case of a test involving an air intake placed to represent the breathing zone of a supine infant). Although the image contained in Fitzgerald's Letter Opinion does not depict the intake for the "'parent' breathing zone," the test as described did involve such an assessment and therefore is reliable and fits the facts of this case well enough for Rule 702 purposes. The jury could regard the demonstration as helpful to its deliberation as to whether powdered asbestos fibers, like powdered talc, become airborne above the level of application during ordinary use. The relative advantages and shortcomings of the methodology go to weight rather than admissibility.

3. Longo

Defendants sought to exclude expert testimony from Fitzgerald concerning studies performed by non-testifying expert Dr. William Longo. They observed that the samples Longo tested are similarly of the wrong provenance and are not reliable based on source mine and chain-of-custody considerations. They also argued that the admission of Longo's opinions through Fitzgerald would be improper because it is hearsay and allows Fitzgerald to simply parrot another expert's opinions.

Fitzgerald has conducted independent testing of JBP samples. In addition, he states that he has "extensively reviewed the testing reported by Dr. William E. Longo, PhD in the report titled: Analysis of Johnson & Johnson Baby Powder and Valiant Shower to Shower Talc Products For amphibole (Tremolite) Asbestos, dated August 2, 2017."

According to Fitzgerald, he has independently "reviewed the testing methodology . . ., the underlying analytical bench sheets, and the photographic documentation of the samples." On that basis, he agreed with Longo's statements concerning his positive findings. Plaintiff argued that because Fitzgerald has reviewed and evaluated Longo's methodology and has expertise in the subject matter, he is not merely parroting another expert's opinion and offers, instead, his own opinion about the reliability of the underlying findings.

In reply, Defendants observed that, in 2002, Longo described asbestos in talc as an "urban legend" and explained that he had performed his own studies but never found it. However, Longo's more recent findings are based on work performed in 2017, evidently involving a new methodology. Also of concern to Defendants is the fact that Longo formed his opinions when he was otherwise engaged as a Plaintiff's expert in asbestos litigation. Defendants maintained that Plaintiff should have called Longo as an expert if they intended to rely on any conclusions he drew from his testing and should not be able to bring Longo's conclusions or testing into this case through Fitzgerald.

An expert may base an opinion on facts or data in the case that the expert has been made aware of or personally observed. If experts in the particular field would reasonably rely on those kinds of facts or data in forming an opinion on the subject, they need not be admissible for the opinion to be admitted.

The Court concluded that Longo's testing of JBP for asbestos contamination falls within the "facts or data in the case" because part of what this trial concerns is the likelihood of asbestos contamination in Johnson & Johnson talc products manufactured across several decades. Here, Fitzgerald has reviewed and analyzed the data that informed Longo's findings and should be permitted to relate them given his own expert qualifications in geology, mineralogy, and electron microscopy, all of which enable him to evaluate the merit of Longo's reported findings and respond to cross-examination concerning the reliability and significance of the methodology Longo employed. In generational, mass torts litigation, it is to be expected that there will be periodic changes in expert witnesses, and this should be allowed to occur without reinventing the wheel or abandoning the facts and data gathered along the way, provided that testifying experts are appropriately versed in the relevant methodology and the earlier data allows for independent evaluation on methodological grounds (as opposed to mere parroting of someone else's findings). The Court recognized that Defendants would prefer for any mention of Longo to include his circa 2002 "urban legend" remark, but that comment does not have so much inherent impeachment weight that it should require that Longo appear as a witness in order for his significantly later electron microscope findings to be a topic of expert discussion in powdered talc mesothelioma cases.

D. Defendants' Motion To Exclude Certain Opinions Of Dr. David Madigan

Plaintiff intended to offer at trial certain opinions from Madigan that are designed to express the statistical likelihood of asbestos exposure and mesothelioma illness based on the extent of a person's use of Defendant's talcum powder products. Defendants challenged Madigan's probability of exposure opinions, any opinion about the causation of mesothelioma trends, and an opinion on the subject of general causation based on an individual's alleged decades-long asbestos exposure.

1. Probability of asbestos exposure

Madigan offered to calculate the probability that a consumer of JBP was not exposed to asbestos based on the number of bottles of JBP used by the consumer. Additionally, he purports to calculate, with a 95-percent prediction interval, the number of asbestos-containing JBP bottles that exist in a population of n total bottles. To do this, he has in part relied on inputs concerning asbestos contamination in bottles of JBP reported by Longo and Fitzgerald.

Here, Madigan has generated a group of calculations based on inputs taken from MAS (Materials Analytical Services LLC), an entity at which Dr. William Longo is CEO. As previously noted in the context of the challenge to Fitzgerald's testimony above, Longo is not designated to testify as an expert witness in this case, though he has a history of testifying as an expert for Plaintiffs in asbestos cases. But Madigan has also generated calculations based on inputs from Fitzgerald, who is designated to testify. Defendants challenge both the Longo inputs and the Fitzgerald inputs.

Madigan would utilize Longo's reported findings in support of his first batch of prediction interval calculations. Evidently, this batch of calculations draws on Longo's report of finding contamination in 18 of 31 bottles, though some of these were not JBP bottles. Defendants objected that the presentation of Madigan's calculations in the absence of any underlying testimony from Longo allows Plaintiff to present to the jury Longo's opinion about the presence of asbestos in JBP without Defendants having the opportunity to cross-examine Longo concerning his alleged findings.

In opposition to the request to exclude that portion of Madigan's opinions that draw on Longo's (or MAS's) findings, Plaintiff asserted that Longo's findings are now established in the peer-reviewed literature and that perhaps Defendants can use their own geology expert, Sanchez, to rebut the opinions of Longo, even though Longo will not appear at trial. The Court is not persuaded that the proper methodology for introducing a non-testifying geologist's opinions is by tucking them inside a statistician's calculations. However, in this case there is a testifying geologist, Fitzgerald, and his testimony has the potential to provide a proper platform for the introduction and consideration of Longo's findings, which in turn serves as a springboard for Madigan to employ the findings in his calculations.

As for Fitzgerald's inputs, Madigan stated that Fitzgerald found contamination in seven of eight bottles of JBP, which he translates to an incident rate of 87%. Defendants noted that such a rate has no real basis, given the size of the set (eight bottles) and Fitzgerald's acknowledgement that he has had several more negative (and positive) findings in his work other than these eight bottles that could inform his personal sample set. However, it appears that some of the studies Fitzgerald conducted are subject to confidentiality and/or non-disclosure agreements. Plaintiff stated simply that "Madigan will offer statistical insights based on his understanding, through his review of other expert testimony and the relevant literature, that JBP does contain asbestos."

Principally, there is no inherent flaw in Madigan's methodology. However, the trick lies in selecting numerators and denominators for purposes of an incident rate. It struck the Court as unreasonable, frankly, to begin with an incident rate of 87% based on a set of only eight samples from Fitzgerald, especially when he acknowledges that he had, but did not maintain records of, negative findings that this sample set does not account for. But the Court agreed with Plaintiff that, ultimately, " Madigan's statistical analysis can be applied to any data set, which means that either side can ask him hypothetical questions based on a predicate assumption about the number of bottles in a population found to contain asbestos." In other words, in the context of a probabilistic assessment based on whatever incident rate the jury concludes is most consistent with the evidence, the provision of expert guidance concerning the corresponding prediction intervals for n bottles can prove helpful to the jury's deliberations. Moreover, the jury is likely to appreciate on its own, especially in the context of cross-examination, that the background evidence does not dictate application of an 87% incident rate. Fitzgerald himself will probably state as much, if his deposition testimony is taken at face value. But the jury will also be assisted if instructed how to consider the impact of differing incident rates on the likelihood that bottles of JBP used by Cartwright would have asbestos contamination, given the number of bottles she is believed to have used in her lifetime. Madigan's expertise and opinion testimony are in this way fitted to the case and should prove helpful to a lay jury unfamiliar with statistical analysis and prediction intervals or predictive inference.

2. Trends

Defendants challenged Madigan's opinion that there is a strong mathematical correlation between the prevalence of cosmetic talc on store shelves and, years later, the incidence rate of mesothelioma in women. In particular, Defendants challenged a graph drawn by Madigan that they say distorts the underlying data to mislead rather than assist the jury. Plaintiff does not concede the point but offers that Madigan has updated the graph in question and will simply use the source graph provided by the government website from which the underlying data is sourced, specifically, the National Cancer Institute's Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results ("SEER") Program. Otherwise, Plaintiff intended to have Madigan speak to the fact that the SEER data shows that the mesothelioma rate for women (while lower than that for men) has decreased in recent years at a slower pace than the decrease observed for men. In response to Defendants' argument that Madigan does not actually purport to see causation in the data, Plaintiff stated that Madigan "will not offer an opinion about the cause for the decline," but will just "present and explain the data." From there, says Plaintiff, "the jury may infer that the slower decline of mesothelioma among women . . . reflects the prevalence of consumer talcum products well into the 2010s, whereas it has been decades since asbestos routinely was deployed in industrial settings."

Because Plaintiff has walked away from the challenged graph prepared by Madigan, that graph is excluded along with any opinion concerning the cause for the "hold up" in the rate of decline in the SEER female mesothelioma data. This ruling does not extend to Madigan's discussion or presentation of the SEER data itself.

3. General causation

Defendants requested the exclusion of any opinion testimony by Madigan on general causation of mesothelioma, i.e., that "there is sufficient evidence that lifetime asbestos exposures as found in regular use of cosmetic talc can cause or contribute to the development of pleural and peritoneal mesothelioma." In particular, Defendants flag the fact that two studies cited by Madigan involved samples with extremely high concentrations of asbestos fibers, whereas samples taken from MAS/Longo involve much lower concentrations. Plaintiff opposed the request with the observation that, among other things, Madigan's review of epidemiological studies will demonstrate that one can "quantify the increased risk of mesothelioma as a function of total asbestos exposure as measured in fiber years."

Based on the Court's review of the record, the Court agreed with Plaintiff that Madigan's general causation opinion would be of assistance to the jury where it is based on several peer-reviewed, epidemiological studies relating specialized knowledge concerning the risk of airborne asbestos exposure measured in fiber years, involves well-accepted principles and methods (e.g., the Bradford Hill criteria), will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue, and is translatable and relevant to the facts of this case. Furthermore, as to the asserted differences in concentration levels, the Court is not convinced that there is no reliable fit between the several studies and the facts of this case and concluded that the alleged discrepancies present a question of weight that the jury will be able to assign with the benefit of cross-examination and input from opposing experts.

On the question of Madigan's expert qualifications, which Defendants challenge with redoubled effort in their Reply, the Court is not persuaded that Madigan needs to be an expert in the areas of asbestos carcinogenesis, asbestos mineralogy, or TEM Microscopy to confer upon the jury findings contained in epidemiological literature concerning the risk of asbestos inhalation. The Court recognizes that Madigan does not have a degree in epidemiology. However, he reports that he has "more than 25 years of experience working in epidemiology" and that he is "an expert in many areas of epidemiology." Additionally, he has "published extensively in epidemiology journals, conducted and/or participated in many epidemiological studies, and consulted for many clients on epidemiological matters." Based on the record, the Court concluded that Madigan possesses the requisite "knowledge" and "experience" to speak on the topic at issue.

Held

  • The Court denied Defendants' motion in limine to exclude the Opinions of Dr. John Godleski.

  • The Court denied Plaintiff's motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. Matthew Sanchez.

  • The Court granted, in limited part, and otherwise denied Defendants' motion to exclude certain opinions of Dr. David Madigan. Madigan will not offer opinion testimony in the form of the challenged graph or concerning the cause for the alleged "hold up" in the rate of decline reflected in the SEER female mesothelioma data.

  • The Court denied Defendants' motion to exclude the opinions of Mr. Sean Fitzgerald. However, on the topic of asbestos inhalation, Fitzgerald's glovebox results will be limited to filters located at a height that is above the application level.

Key Takeaway

Reliance on other experts is not inherently problematic—experts routinely build their testimony on top of inputs drawn from other experts—but it becomes a problem if the non-testifying expert's inputs do not plug into the testifying expert's methodology without raising reliability concerns in the context of the testifying expert's own methodology. One version of this concern arises when the testifying expert serves as a Trojan horse who smuggles in another expert's opinions even though the testifying expert has no relevant expertise to speak on the reliability of the smuggled opinions. This concern has varyingly been referred to as involving an expert who would amount to a "parrot," "ventriloquist dummy," "mouthpiece," or mere "conduit."

Case Details:

Case Caption:

Curtin V. Johnson & Johnson

Docket Number:

2:24cv427

Court Name:

United States District Court for the District of Maine

Order Date:

June 23, 2026